I’ve likely watched movies since Sherlock Holmes, but I can’t remember what they were.
Clearly, I did not review them. My blog is mostly dead, but as Miracle Max made clear “There’s a big difference between mostly dead and all dead.”
So I watched Alice in Wonderland this weekend in 3D. It seemed to use a different kind of 3D than Avatar, and that certainly didn’t play to its advantage. I’m not sure there was much to be gained by the 3D treatment.
Tim Burton is weird. I know that some of my friends love his work, but I generally leave the theater feeling as if I spent the last two hours of my life fighting off insanity.
Of his many films, there is only one that I really liked and that was Big Fish. And yes, that includes Batman. Sure, it was good when it was the only Batman we had, but Christopher Nolan has shown us a great Batman. Tim Burton’s is a joke.
So it comes as no surprise to myself that I found Alice in Wonderland to be primarily meh. It wasn’t a waste of my time, but it was also not a great use of my time. I didn’t laugh, I didn’t cry, and I didn’t marvel.
Instead, I just questioned the sanity of the filmmaker and spent my time trying to figure out if Johnny Depp meant to switch accents in every scene. Depp is usually a solid performer even in Burton’s messy movies, but here he seemed a little lost. Then again, he was playing the Mad Hatter so maybe that was the point.
The only bright spot for me was the realization that the White Queen (played by Anne Hathaway) was modeled after the white queen of the chess board. Having never read the books, I had never realized that both queens were based on separate games.
Sadly, I could have come to that realization via Wikipedia.
The Cheshire Cat was pretty entertaining and his ability to vanish on demand was used to great effect. He was probably the strongest character, despite a solid cast of actors.
If you like Tim Burton, you’ll probably like Alice in Wonderland. If you have nothing better to watch, it won’t feel like a total waste of your time because Anne Hathaway is hot (even when painted white) and the Cheshire Cat is slick.
Verdict: C+ Tilt: D

