Although many will say that the latter trilogy of Star Wars was a travesty compared to the original trilogy, I submit to you that they are about equal.
The only difference is a lot of nostalgia and possibly more charismatic actors. But only slightly.
Mark Hammill isn’t that far removed from Hayden Christensen on the horrible actor scale. Carrie Fisher isn’t even half the actress that Natalie Portman is.
Yet, they all sucked in Star Wars.
Ewan McGregor, Liam Neeson, Natalie Portman, Samuel L. Jackson, Alec Guinness, Harrison Ford, James Earl Jones — they all delivered poor acting performances in their respective Star Wars movies.
You may be cursing me right now, but it’s the awful honest truth.
All of the Star Wars movies have the worst display of acting ability in the entire universe, as well as galaxies far far away.
We could blame these great actors for phoning it in, but I think the real blame lies with one man — George Lucas.
George Lucas is quite simply devoid of directing talent. He couldn’t direct his way out of a seedy cantina on Tattooine, much less a blockbuster film.
Yet, Star Wars lives on as one of the greatest movie franchises of all time. But why?
Because for what George Lucas lacks in directing talent, he makes up for in great writing and character concepts.
Star Wars is one of the most familiar, yet unique, stories every told.
I watched Episode III recently and I realized that some of the plot devices that he’s trying so desperately to bring to the big screen are actually quite clever.
The angst, the anger, and the confusion of Anakin is all there in the viewer’s imagination. But never on screen. On screen, Anakin has one emotion — anger.
I hope that 40 years from now when Lucas has left his estate to his family and Star Wars is but a distant memory of the old folks, someone has the rights and the guts to remake the Star Wars movies.
It may sound like blasphemy, but there are some great stories and characters there that deserve to be brought to the big screen by a director who can really bring this stuff to life by more than just special effects.
There. I’ve said it. Star Wars sucks.