Okay. Maybe I don’t really hate it. I just hate to watch year after year and see the best contestants get voted off.
I’m pretty anti-social and my general stance on people other than myself (and those few who have proven otherwise) is that they’re all morons.
American Idol proves how moronic America really is. Every single year.
The only seasons that America had even half a brain were Seasons one & four.
I’m not a big fan of Kelly Clarkson, but I’ll admit she’s a bona fide artist at this point.
And, of course, I think the world of Carrie Underwood who is — by my estimation — the most worthy American Idol winner ever.
The year after Carrie, Chris Daughtry got an early boot when he should have won. And who won instead? Taylor Hicks.
Seriously, I don’t understand the reasoning people use when voting for these contestants. I’m willing to concede that not every one has to have the same taste in music, but it’s not always about musical genre.
It’s about actual talent. There are haves and have-nots when it comes to a fantastic singing voice, and the division is generally very very clear.
But apparently no one’s ears work as well as mine, because I’m continually disappointed by the decisions made by the loyal viewers of idol.
This year we had a final six of Jason Castro, Syesha Mercado, Brooke White, David Cook, David Archuleta and Carly Smithson.
That’s a solid final six, but let’s face facts. Both Syesha and Jason are amateurs compared to the other four. Their voices are weak, their choices are boring, and they have no real chance in the world of music.
Yet somehow, Carly got voted out. Carly; the woman who has the best female vocals by far in this year’s competition.
Brooke couldn’t even sing her song right, yet somehow she got voted through. She’s a snotty, arrogant little brat who constantly interrupts the judges and is in all other ways rude from what I’ve seen on Idol.
Yet America persists. Bunch of morons.
http://votefortheworst.com
Someone agrees with you.
I do agree with you about Brooke – yuk! AI is just a reality TV show – why do people get so up in arms about who wins and who is booted – Most of the real rock and country stars do not come from AI anyway. AI is just all about entertainment and even though we may hate it – we are entertained.
Call me a moron, but I thought the best season was Season 5 – and I think the right guy won. Taylor Hicks may not sell records, but we were sure entertained each week. I like Daughtry too, but I still think the best man won. Please don’t tell me you like David Archuletta – what a bore – great voice but no personality – I’m rooting for David Cook, but I won’t lose sleep if he doesn’t win. If Archuletta wins – I’ll never watch again – ha! I’ll be there next year just like you – you moron!
Gotta agree with you on all counts. I watch when i’m in the room cuz it’s the program choice of the majority. Here’s hoping the music producers are picking up the talent. Stopping a song is all about self-i’ve seen lots of great performers sing the wrong line and still keep on to please the audience. sorry i cant remember who anyone is but i was amazed when i wandered thru the performance of “bilie jean”. i get my ai info from the tabloids ;).